A very tranquil scene which suits the panoramic format very well. The subtle colours have been captured beautifully.The horizon doesn't appear level but this could be an illusion due to the curvature of the lakes edge. Some might argue that the white area where the sun has set is blown out but that is often how it looks to the eye.

Nicely exposed giving good tonal range. Good over all balance . Just hasn’t got the impact or interest  to hold me.

like the format and those beautiful morning tones. Shame there was not an object to give the image a bit more impact

I like the panoramic crop of the image and the tones of the receding hills.  Lovely light and reflection.

Another lovely  serene panorama. The only comment I would make is that I would prefer a large crop off the top to focus my attention on the beautiful light on the edge of the lake.

I feel this image is need to been under exposed by one or two stops to bring out the colour that is there. Try using levels in photoshop Input 125  1.00   255.

nice tones,just lacks contrast and again that something to focus on for impact. Try a longer lens and much less sky.

What a lovely place it is.  I feel this has too much sky making the horizon very central.  Nice tones.

Do you need all that sky? Your image is in the fenceline (a nice diagonal) with the background hills there to hold your interest into the image, thus, I would crop the sky down to just above the lower clouds. A little less exposure (adjustment in levels) would be helpful too. Better still, go back in a lower lighting condition!

This shot has a ton of potential. Good composition with fence leading the eye in. More contrast and colour saturation would give it a bit of punch. If it were me I would crop out the isolated cloud at the top, a small crop off the bottom and crop the left to almost halfway to the first post. I think there is a little too much ground to the left of the first post.

Nice lead in line with the fence. Well composed. I feel the exposure could underexposed by half  a stop giving more impact to the image.

I do like the fenceline leading into the hills behind and the contrast of the grass with the bare paddock but it could do with the late golden sunlight to give it more drama.

Good sewing, Karen! Perhaps a little more foreground to balance the sky and an exposure adjustment to bring out the depth of colour in the hills and sky would be helpful.

Well stitched up!! A nice panorama. Like the first shot, it would benefit with a little less exposure and a little more contrast and colour saturation. I would have liked to see a little more foreground and a little less sky, but I realise that there might have been something there that did not suit.

A very well stiched image giving a lovely panorama.  Great depth of interest looking up the valley to the mountains. Underexposed a half a stop or in levels bring the level up to give it more impact. 

nice to see a panorama, an area that I have been working on and enjoy. Lovely subject and well handled, but again lacking in nice contrast. Try Levels adj. "18  90 228" should bring out the lovely mood and colour.

Well done on your first stitched panorama.  The image(s) is well exposed and shows the majesty of the hills.  It could be given a little more punch by increasing the contrast slightly and darkening the blue sky.

Nice mood in this one Karen but rather too burnt out in the highlight areas. Some darkening around the right hand side of the image would help contain the brighter areas.

A moody atmospheric shot with lovely lighting on the cloud. The foreground and the sea need to be sharp.  In spite of this, it is still a very nice image.

I like the moody scene. It may be my monitor, but there appears to be a halo around the rock and the sea horizon/coastline on the left side.

I like the composition of this image and the pastel tones.  The sky could be burnt in a bit more for extra drama and careful cloning around the land could get rid of the halo effect.

I can almost feel the damp here, Karen. I like the arrangement of the hills but again I would like to see the left hand and top edges darkened off a little to help hold the eye into the image.

I like this very much, moody and mysterious. I wouldn't change anything.

This is a nice image I agree the sepia adds to the overall image. Lovely composition and the mist in the valley portrays the Haast Valley very well

The sepia tone has made this into a very nice moody image.

The monotone sepia effect is well used here and enhances the feeling of the image.  Again I would like to see the top left corner darkened down as my eye keeps going up to the bright cloud and out of the image.